Cottage Cheese Bagels: A Unique High-Protein Twist on a Classic Favorite

Cottage cheese bagels are taking over breakfast menus—and for good reason. These chewy, golden beauties are packed with protein, easy to make, and completely free of added sugar. Whether you’re trying to eat fewer refined carbs or just want a more nourishing way to enjoy your morning bagel, this recipe checks every box.

Unlike traditional bagels, which rely on flour, yeast, and sugar, this version uses creamy blended cottage cheese to create a soft, satisfying dough. You’ll only need a few ingredients, no rising time, and zero guilt. Plus, they’re oven- and air-fryer-friendly, so you can enjoy them any time, no matter your schedule.

In this article, we’ll cover the benefits of making your own cottage cheese bagel, compare it to popular versions like Bethenny Frankel’s viral recipe, and answer common questions like “Is cottage cheese good for bagels?” and “What does it pair well with?” You’ll also learn how to enjoy your favorite bagel and cottage cheese combo in brand-new ways.

Let’s kick things off with the personal story behind my go-to cottage cheese bagel recipe, and how this little creation became a staple in my sugar-free kitchen.

In this post

Print

The Story & Intro: How Cottage Cheese Bagels Became My Sugar-Free Staple

Cottage cheese bagels were never something I grew up with—but I wish they had been. Back in my grandmother’s kitchen, the aroma of baking bread filled the air most weekends. We’d make everything from sweet banana loaves to buttery rolls, but bagels? Those were store-bought, sugary, and always left me feeling tired by mid-morning. Fast forward to my late twenties, and everything changed.

When I was diagnosed with insulin resistance, I knew I had to rethink how I baked—and what I put into my body. Out went the sugar. Out went the white flour. In came experimentation, late-night testing, and a ton of flops. But then came the real breakthrough: cottage cheese bagels.

At first, the idea of blending cottage cheese into dough sounded strange. But once I gave it a try, I never looked back. The texture was soft, chewy, and incredibly satisfying. And unlike traditional recipes, this one didn’t spike my blood sugar or leave me crashing an hour later. With every batch, I realized more and more just how powerful this simple, protein-rich ingredient could be.

Now, my cottage cheese bagel recipe is a regular part of my weekly prep. I blend the cottage cheese until smooth, mix it with self-rising flour, and shape the dough into golden rings of goodness. No yeast. No rising time. Just pure joy. I bake a dozen at a time and freeze most for easy weekday breakfasts. One quick toast, and I’ve got a warm, satisfying bagel with cottage cheese that fits perfectly into my sugar-free lifestyle.

Want to know the best part? They’re endlessly versatile. I love mine topped with smashed avocado, smoked salmon, or a fried egg with microgreens. For something sweet, try almond butter with cinnamon or sugar-free berry jam.

And if you’re curious about how these compare to other clean baking favorites, you’ll love pairing them with my fluffy almond flour pancakes or these sugar-free cinnamon rolls. They’re all built on the same belief: food should love you back.

Making these cottage cheese bagels was more than a kitchen experiment—it became part of my healing journey. If you’re just starting your sugar-free path or just want a smarter way to enjoy carbs, this recipe might just change the way you see bagels forever.

How to Make Cottage Cheese Bagels at Home (No Sugar, No Yeast)

Once you realize how easy it is to make cottage cheese bagels, it’s hard to go back to store-bought. This method takes less than 30 minutes from start to finish and uses only a handful of ingredients. Whether you prefer baking or air frying, both versions come out beautifully golden and packed with flavor.

Let’s break down exactly how to bring this cottage cheese bagel recipe to life in your own kitchen.

Ingredients for Cottage Cheese Bagels (Makes 4)

• 1 cup cottage cheese (full-fat or low-fat, blended until smooth)
• 1 cup self-rising flour
  (or 1 cup all-purpose flour + 2 tsp baking powder + ¼ tsp salt)
• 1 egg white (for brushing)
• Optional toppings: sesame seeds, everything bagel seasoning, poppy seeds

Step-by-Step: Cottage Cheese Bagel Recipe (Oven + Air Fryer)

To make these bagels with cottage cheese, you only need three main ingredients: blended cottage cheese, self-rising flour, and an egg for brushing. If you’re using all-purpose flour, just add baking powder and salt to make it self-rising.

Here’s how I make mine:

1. Blend the cottage cheese
   Start with one cup of full-fat cottage cheese. Use a blender or food processor to puree it until smooth. This gives the bagels a soft, even texture. Don’t skip this step—it makes all the difference.
2. Mix the dough
   Transfer the cottage cheese to a mixing bowl. Add one cup of self-rising flour and stir until a dough forms. It should be soft but not sticky. If needed, add a sprinkle of flour.
3. Knead and divide
   Knead gently for 1–2 minutes until the dough is smooth. Divide into four equal pieces.
4. Shape your bagels
   Roll each piece into a rope (about 6–7 inches long), then join the ends to form a ring. Press the seam gently to seal.
5. Add toppings (optional)
   Brush each ring with egg white. Top with sesame seeds, everything seasoning, or poppy seeds if desired.
6. Bake or air fry
   Oven: Bake at 375°F on the top rack for 25–28 minutes until golden.
   Air Fryer: Preheat to 350°F, then cook for 12–14 minutes. Check for doneness early, as cook time varies.

Once baked, let your cottage cheese bagels cool for 15 minutes before slicing. They’re best enjoyed warm or toasted.

I love pairing them with a dollop of my herbed cashew spread or as the base for an open-faced egg sandwich with sliced avocado and spinach. They also freeze well, making them ideal for meal prep.

Can You Use Cottage Cheese Instead of Yogurt?

This is one of the most common questions about homemade protein bagels. So let’s settle it: Can you use cottage cheese instead of yogurt in bagels? Yes—100%.

Cottage cheese offers the same binding and moisture that Greek yogurt does, but with even more protein per serving. When blended smooth, it creates the same creamy consistency and a slightly richer flavor. I’ve tested both, and while yogurt-based bagels are great, I prefer cottage cheese bagels for their soft crumb and golden finish.

Plus, cottage cheese is more forgiving in the oven. It holds moisture better, which helps avoid that dry, chalky texture some high-protein baked goods have. That’s a big win for anyone transitioning into a sugar-free or low-carb lifestyle.

Looking for more recipes that use cottage cheese in creative ways? Try my Cottage cheese banana bread or Cottage cheese protein banana bread—perfect protein-packed additions to your meal rotation.

Delicious Ways to Serve Bagel and Cottage Cheese Combos

Once you’ve made your batch of fresh, golden cottage cheese bagels, the fun really begins. These versatile bagels are more than a breakfast food—they’re the perfect base for both savory and sweet creations. Whether you’re building a protein-packed lunch or an afternoon snack, your bagel with cottage cheese can be transformed in endless ways.

Toppings That Pair Perfectly with Cottage Cheese Bagels

So, what does cottage cheese pair well with? A lot. Because of its creamy, slightly tangy flavor, cottage cheese works beautifully with both salty and sweet toppings. When paired with the chewy texture of a cottage cheese bagel, you get the best of both worlds—flavor and nutrition in one bite.

Here are some of my favorite topping ideas for your next bagel and cottage cheese masterpiece:

Savory Toppings	Sweet Toppings
Sliced avocado + sea salt + red pepper flakes	Sugar-free jam + almond butter
Smoked salmon + whipped cottage cheese + dill	Cottage cheese + cinnamon + crushed walnuts
Scrambled eggs + spinach + hot sauce	Mashed banana + sugar-free chocolate chips

These combinations turn your cottage cheese bagels into full meals—rich in protein and free from added sugar.

For even more topping inspiration, check out my Cottage cheese almond flour banana bread and Cottage cheese banana bread no flour—both made to elevate your bagel experience without spiking your blood sugar.

How to Make Bethenny Frankel’s Viral Cottage Cheese Bagel?

You’ve probably heard of the TikTok-famous Bethenny Frankel cottage cheese bagel. So how does her version compare?

Her take is similar to the classic 2-ingredient high-protein bagel: cottage cheese and self-rising flour. What makes it stand out is the simplicity—no yeast, no rising time, and often done in the air fryer. While her recipe focuses on minimalism, my version adds an extra step by blending the cottage cheese, which gives the final bagel a smoother, more tender bite.

If you want to replicate her version:

• Use 1 cup cottage cheese + 1 cup self-rising flour
• Mix, shape, and air fry at 350°F for 12–14 minutes
• Skip the egg wash if you’re avoiding eggs
• Sprinkle everything bagel seasoning before air frying

While it’s definitely a solid shortcut, I find that blending the cottage cheese and brushing with egg white adds just a little extra magic to the texture and look.

For a slightly different spin, try pairing your cottage cheese bagel with my homemade tomato basil spread for a Mediterranean twist.

FAQs + Storage Tips for Cottage Cheese Bagels

Now that you’ve got the recipe and toppings down, let’s answer some of the most common questions about cottage cheese bagels and how to keep them fresh, delicious, and ready when you need them. This part is all about making your healthy bagel habit sustainable.

Conclusion: Bagels That Love You Back

Cottage cheese bagels are more than just a trend—they’re a better way to enjoy a timeless favorite. Whether you’re avoiding sugar, balancing your blood sugar, or simply looking for a satisfying breakfast that fits your real life, this cottage cheese bagel recipe delivers.

It’s easy, quick, and flexible enough to fit into any routine. With a few ingredients and a little prep, you’ve got chewy, protein-rich bagels you can feel great about. No refined sugar, no long wait times—just real food, made simply.

If you’re just beginning your sugar-free journey or simply want a smarter way to indulge, I hope this recipe becomes a staple in your kitchen like it has in mine.

Looking for your next baking adventure? You’ll also love my sugar-free banana muffins and easy almond flour tortillas—two more no-guilt favorites that won’t let you down.

Join No Sugar Bakes on Facebook for simple, satisfying recipes made to fit your sugar-free lifestyle.
Browse No Sugar Bakes on Pinterest for delicious ways to enjoy sweetness—without the sugar.